Introductions and General Posts >> The Forces in the News >> Poll: Argentina and Falklands - First it was Sovereignty, now it's Oil

+3

Poll: Argentina and Falklands - First it was Sovereignty, now it's Oil

2,798 Views
99 Replies Flag as inappropriate

Poll: Should we send a Royal Navy ship or Sub to the Falklands as a gesture of intent?

Sixnations_max50

623 posts

back to top

Posted about 1 year ago

 

FALKLAND ISLANDS Ministry of Defence steps up surveillance of Argentinian navy as tensions escalate over black gold in the Falkland Islands.


The Argies have also tried to blokade British registered ships from delivering oil rig equipment to the Islands, defying the International trade exclusion zone agreed upon after the '82 war.


How will this row pan out and will the Argies ever give up their expansionist claims to foreign territory?


Cooperation destroys Confrontation

Bild15_max50

20870 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

There are already rumours flying about that there are a couple of ships on the way down there, the MOD has denied this, who do we believe? I believe the MOD at the moment as the rumours are being circulated by The Sun newspaper! lol


Women should be obscene and not heard!

Never regret what you have done, only what you havent!!!!

Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com! border=0 /

Charles_max50

266 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Yes and remember The Sun is always right!


If the Train to Heaven Stops at Bangkok, GET OFF!

Captain-_max50

44 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

The FCO should make it clear what our intentions are - we don't want a repeat of the confusion over that as in '82.

Images_max50

255 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

oggmonster says ...



The FCO should make it clear what our intentions are - we don't want a repeat of the confusion over that as in '82.



Don't sit on the fence mate - speak your mind. Listen we should storm in there when the time's right and batter them again. The Falklands is a sovereign Island with a people that don't want Spanish control.


The only preference I have is swatting Muslim extremists...

Dannie_on_doozertruck_2_ogden_max50

260 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

 the aggies are barking,time to put a muzzel on. or send a vet,or two. recon theres a few scores to settle  from our vetrans. but joking aside we should make full use of our capabilaties,and let them know the door is,and will always be closed. dannie. (old git+vat)

0 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

The aggies  are only doing this becaus thers oil involved, if the falklands was just hills and grass tahy would not want to no about it

Raf_crest_small_max50

2092 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

I was under the impression we had a small navy presence (around 2 ships) down there already as well as a sqdrn of tornado's/typhoons and some army? Has the situation escalated that muhc or is it just the argie bargie's doing their usual moaning like a child without a sweet and the media blowing it up? 


Never give up, never quit, if you havent bled you haven't earnt it.

Bild15_max50

20870 posts

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted about 1 year ago

 

whitey14uk says ...



I was under the impression we had a small navy presence (around 2 ships) down there already as well as a sqdrn of tornado's/typhoons and some army? Has the situation escalated that muhc or is it just the argie bargie's doing their usual moaning like a child without a sweet and the media blowing it up? 



We have got a small force down there mate!


Thing is, where are we going to get the troops from if this does escalate????.


Women should be obscene and not heard!

Never regret what you have done, only what you havent!!!!

Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com! border=0 /

Captain-_max50

44 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

buggerLuggs says ...



oggmonster says ...



The FCO should make it clear what our intentions are - we don't want a repeat of the confusion over that as in '82.



Don't sit on the fence mate - speak your mind. Listen we should storm in there when the time's right and batter them again. The Falklands is a sovereign Island with a people that don't want Spanish control.



You would (sit that is) if you were in my position!!! Yesterday the MoD denied the Royal Navy had increased its presence in the South Atlantic. But four vessels - HMS York, the survey ship HMS Scott, the Falklands patrol vessel HMS Clyde and the tanker RFA Wave Ruler - are close to the territory. A military source said top brass had ordered four Eurofighter Typhoon fighters, which carry 1,000lb laser-guided missiles, to fly to the south Atlantic, replacing the RAF's ageing Tornado fighters, which cannot carry bombs. Just a coincidence? The MoD said the changeover of planes was routine and not a response to the threats by Argentina.

Sixnations_max50

623 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

dreme says ...



whitey14uk says ...



I was under the impression we had a small navy presence (around 2 ships) down there already as well as a sqdrn of tornado's/typhoons and some army? Has the situation escalated that muhc or is it just the argie bargie's doing their usual moaning like a child without a sweet and the media blowing it up? 



We have got a small force down there mate!


Thing is, where are we going to get the troops from if this does escalate????.



We still have some excellent soldiers. The problem is getting them there. So what should we do? Well, in honour of the 258 brave men who gave their lives in 1982 and to support the proudly British Falkland Islanders, it is essential that we do something. What we're seeing may just be a bit of sabre-rattling, an attempt by Argentine President de Kirchner to distract the electorate from her own problems.


Cooperation destroys Confrontation

Captain-_max50

44 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

But sabre-rattling quickly becomes something more when you can scent weakness in your enemy.

World-usa2003_max50

5487 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

I don't think a sub or for that matter anymore forces should be sent to the region - to my knowledge the navy already has a frigate down their on exercise anyway.


This doesn't mean that forces should not be made ready, i'd think that it would be easily achievable to get a sufficient force to be put on 24hrs notice to move.


However the direct movement of armed force into the region, in my opinion, will only worsen the situation and put the UK at greater risk of entering armed conflict.



So basically my view have the forces on stand by in the UK but do not deploy to the region as if a conflict is to break out the UK dose not want to look like the antagonist


Please call me TOM !!!

"A man who won't die for something is not fit to live" - Martin Luther King, Jr.
"To all my enemies, I will destroy you" - Frankie Boyle
"Observe everthing admire nothing"

Raf_crest_small_max50

2092 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

WELBURN75 says ...



I don't think a sub or for that matter anymore forces should be sent to the region - to my knowledge the navy already has a frigate down their on exercise anyway.


This doesn't mean that forces should not be made ready, i'd think that it would be easily achievable to get a sufficient force to be put on 24hrs notice to move.


However the direct movement of armed force into the region, in my opinion, will only worsen the situation and put the UK at greater risk of entering armed conflict.



So basically my view have the forces on stand by in the UK but do not deploy to the region as if a conflict is to break out the UK dose not want to look like the antagonist



Got to disagree there big fella.


 


Firstly 24 hours notice to move is all fine and well, i can assure you we have RQA forces ready to move much sooner than that, I think what you mean is 24 hours to get there if it kicks off. That's not likely when it comes to naval forces, would take approx 3 days to get there.


Secondly  there is already an armed forces presence in the area as it stands, in referenvce to an earlier post there's been plans to send typhoon's to the falklands for a while to replace the tornado's. Maybe its coincidental timing, maybe its a show of force, or maybe its a bit of both.


I can assure you if we did send extra forces down there it would not make us the antagonist, the falklands are ours, the islanders are british and they want us there, they're our people. Someone starts pushing your mate around, by clenching your fist are you the antagonist?


If the argie bargie's did fancy a pop they''d have a job, part of my job is radar's and I promise you with the type of systems we have down there we'd see them comming a mile off, or a few hundred mile off... nuff said on that.


Can someoe brifly fill me in on all of this? I've had a hectic week at work so I havewnt kept up with the news, last I heard we want to probe for oil around the islands and the Argie's dont like it? Whats happened since then to kick talk off of military action?


Never give up, never quit, if you havent bled you haven't earnt it.

World-usa2003_max50

5487 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

whitey14uk says ...



Got to disagree there big fella.


 


Firstly 24 hours notice to move is all fine and well, i can assure you we have RQA forces ready to move much sooner than that, I think what you mean is 24 hours to get there if it kicks off. That's not likely when it comes to naval forces, would take approx 3 days to get there.


Secondly  there is already an armed forces presence in the area as it stands, in reference to an earlier post there's been plans to send typhoon's to the Falklands for a while to replace the tornado's. Maybe its coincidental timing, maybe its a show of force, or maybe its a bit of both.


I can assure you if we did send extra forces down there it would not make us the antagonist, the Falklands are ours, the islanders are British and they want us there, they're our people. Someone starts pushing your mate around, by clenching your fist are you the antagonist?


If the argie bargie's did fancy a pop they''d have a job, part of my job is radar's and I promise you with the type of systems we have down there we'd see them comming a mile off, or a few hundred mile off... nuff said on that.


Can someoe brifly fill me in on all of this? I've had a hectic week at work so I havewnt kept up with the news, last I heard we want to probe for oil around the islands and the Argie's dont like it? Whats happened since then to kick talk off of military action?



Some very fair points - and with regard to the 24hrs notice i meant like you said to be down their, but i was mean land forces, as I'm aware naval assets would take a while longer to get down their.


However i do think that the placment of more force in the region, however we the brits may view it, the rest of the world may see it as a move to force the argentinians into conflict.


As for why all the talk of military action i think its a mix of the press and politicians - http://www.hmforces.co.uk/news/articles/2148-argentine-anger-as-british-oil-rig-moves-in-today-and-mod-increases-forces -


"Gordon Brown responded to Argentinian sabre-rattling by insisting yesterday that the UK had made ‘all the preparations that are necessary’ to protect the territory, which has a population of 3,000.


But Shadow Foreign Secretary William Hague said the Royal Navy’s presence in the region should be increased further to act as a deterrent."


 but i think the talk of war - but please don't quote me on this - is due to the Argie's demanding permits for some of the ships that are aiding the exploration, Or at least that's how i understand it.


Please call me TOM !!!

"A man who won't die for something is not fit to live" - Martin Luther King, Jr.
"To all my enemies, I will destroy you" - Frankie Boyle
"Observe everthing admire nothing"

Raf_crest_small_max50

2092 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Cheers Tom!


Seems to me they need to be put back in their place.


My vote is a show of force,


We still have guys and girls good to go.


Never give up, never quit, if you havent bled you haven't earnt it.

0 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

I think we will have US backing this time if anything kicks off

Bild15_max50

20870 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Highlander2010 says ...



I think we will have US backing this time if anything kicks off



I hope so mate, cos I cant see us getting enough troops together without making cut-backs elsewhere. Plus we all know what they are like when oil is involved, they will be straight in there!


Women should be obscene and not heard!

Never regret what you have done, only what you havent!!!!

Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com! border=0 /

0 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

We Might get a call up all 18 to 45 year olds

Raf_crest_small_max50

2092 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Highlander2010 says ...



We Might get a call up all 18 to 45 year olds



Lol I don't see it getting that drastic!


Never give up, never quit, if you havent bled you haven't earnt it.

23290_7603938238_9658_n_max50

1426 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

LOL


 


Now now guys..take a wee look at the Argintine Forces...they have not had hardly any new kit or combat experience since 1982....


the UK forces on the otherhand.......


The Tech on the Typhoon alone would scare the arse of of their Airforce......


 


And the idea the Yanks would not support us is mad......look at Afghan right now, we leg it they have a wee bit of bother eh ?


 


Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com!<br

23290_7603938238_9658_n_max50

1426 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

A quick run down on their Airforce.......still depends on the Skyhawk and Mirage for the hard Sell 


 


Aircraft Origin Type Versions Quantity


 Fighter Aircraft Dassault Mirage III  France Fighter/Trainer Mirage IIIEA/Mirage IIIDA  


McDonnell Douglas A-4 Skyhawk  United States Attack and fighter

Attack, fighter and trainer A-4AR/OA-4AR 20


IAI Finger (Mirage 5 subtype)  Israel Attack and fighter/Trainer Finger/Dagger B 6


Dassault Mirage V  France Attack and fighter Mirage 5A 6


Ground Attack FMA IA 58 Pucará  Argentina Attack IA-58A 36 


  Trainer Beechcraft T-34 Mentor  United States Trainer FMA T-34A 31 


  Sukhoi Su-29  Russia Aerobatics Su-29 7  


Embraer Tucano  Brazil Trainer   27  


FMA IA 63 Pampa  Argentina Trainer/attack   18


 


Info from Wiki of course


Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com!<br

Bild15_max50

20870 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Highlander2010 says ...



We Might get a call up all 18 to 45 year olds



aaaaaaaawww!!! Missed it again!lol


Women should be obscene and not heard!

Never regret what you have done, only what you havent!!!!

Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com! border=0 /

23290_7603938238_9658_n_max50

1426 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Tartanninja says ...



A quick run down on their Airforce.......still depends on the Skyhawk and Mirage for the hard Sell 


 


Aircraft Origin Type Versions Quantity


 Fighter Aircraft Dassault Mirage III  France Fighter/Trainer Mirage IIIEA/Mirage IIIDA  


McDonnell Douglas A-4 Skyhawk  United States Attack and fighter

Attack, fighter and trainer A-4AR/OA-4AR 20


IAI Finger (Mirage 5 subtype)  Israel Attack and fighter/Trainer Finger/Dagger B 6


Dassault Mirage V  France Attack and fighter Mirage 5A 6


Ground Attack FMA IA 58 Pucará  Argentina Attack IA-58A 36 


  Trainer Beechcraft T-34 Mentor  United States Trainer FMA T-34A 31 


  Sukhoi Su-29  Russia Aerobatics Su-29 7  


Embraer Tucano  Brazil Trainer   27  


FMA IA 63 Pampa  Argentina Trainer/attack   18


 


Info from Wiki of course


And ours...of course you can take a lot of this out because of Afghan.....and remember the Apache is owned by the ARMY..


 




AIRCRAFT TYPE
FLEET NUMBER


Typhoon
54


Tornado GR4/4A
136


Tornado F3
64


Harrier
77


Nimrod MR2
15


Nimrod R1
3


Nimrod MRA4
1


Tristar
9


VC10
15


Sentry
7


Sentinel
5


Hercules K
14


Hercules J
24


C-17
6


BAe 146
2


BAe 125
6


Sea King
25


Dominie
9



Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com!<br

Raf_crest_small_max50

2092 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

I was looking at that same page earlier today, made me chuckle that some of their kit is before my dads time! Their infantry weapons are getting on now as well.


In terms of our kit, I'd take a few off the numbers ofd the Tornado F3's and add a few to the typhoons. We've dismantled a fair few tornado's as they're being replaced by the typhoons.


Don't forget  Globe masters, its a good peice of kit, even if it is american, I wouldn;t be suprised if we have an E3D (AWAC) near by these days to keep an eye on stuff.


They can't sneeze without us knowing about it.


Never give up, never quit, if you havent bled you haven't earnt it.

23290_7603938238_9658_n_max50

1426 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Their Infantry gear is light years behind us......the newest bit of kit they got was the Styer AUG....


and even thats old by todays Standard.....


 


Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com!<br

Raf_crest_small_max50

2092 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Tartanninja says ...



Their Infantry gear is light years behind us......the newest bit of kit they got was the Styer AUG....


and even thats old by todays Standard.....


 



Not a chance against our lads.


Never give up, never quit, if you havent bled you haven't earnt it.

23290_7603938238_9658_n_max50

1426 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Roger that.....


 


Big bucket of oil anyone ?


Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com!<br

Raf_crest_small_max50

2092 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

Tartanninja says ...



Roger that.....


 


Big bucket of oil anyone ?



I fancy a few thousand! Anyone got a problem with that?


Never give up, never quit, if you havent bled you haven't earnt it.

Bild15_max50

20870 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 year ago

 

whitey14uk says ...



Tartanninja says ...



Roger that.....


 


Big bucket of oil anyone ?



I fancy a few thousand! Anyone got a problem with that?



Careful oh fluffy one, its reet mucky stuff!.


Women should be obscene and not heard!

Never regret what you have done, only what you havent!!!!

Create your own banner at mybannermaker.com! border=0 /

Next Page >